December 23, 2014

Branding and Pop-Tarts

I was recently shopping for Pop-Tarts… I mean, “pastry treats,” as defined by my favorite store brand. As I continue to try stretching our grocery budget to feed our four kids still at home, the cheaper product was beginning to look better and better.
   
 It wasn’t about any fancy packaging. To me, it just mattered if my kids would eat them, and how much of my disposable grocery budget was spent on the quick and easy breakfast food. 

The truth was that I’d tried switching before, and it didn’t go over so well.  However, I decided to give the store brand another try without flaunting the stand-ins box. In other words, I hid the switcheroo from my kids, and I thought I’d gotten away with the change until my 12-year-old remarked, “I don’t like those other pop-tarts. They are all frosting and no filling.”

I understood what he meant. Although we buy plenty of other store brand food items (pasta, butter, eggs, orange juice….), I only buy Heinz ketchup and Prego spaghetti sauce because I really do prefer the taste over the other national or store brands. Thus, we’re back to being brand loyal to Pop-Tarts, stocking up when they go on sale, using coupons and “eating” that small amount of money not saved.

According to Marketing Expert Laura Lake, we’re not alone. Lake states, “Your brand resides within the hearts and minds of customers, clients, and prospects. It is the sum total of their experiences and perceptions, some of which you can influence, and some that you cannot.”

In this case, it was the taste that prompted my kid’s comment and ultimately the deal-breaker for the pop-tart dilemma, but what is influencing your branding? Like the “pasty treats” scenario, is your target audience willing to dismiss the bells and whistles of your “box” to choose your product if price is one of your strategies? Or, is your poor image portrayed by some things you’ve overlooked – the user-friendliness of your website, the professionalism of your signage, your lack of accessibility, and more – overshadowing your quality product? How well does your packaging reflect your company?

According to KiSSmetrics, unlike marketing, which is the set of processes and tools that promote your business, branding is the culture itself – the message that permeates and rules all the processes of your business. 
 
For now, we’ll stick to our Pop-Tarts. Is your branding resulting in customers that are just as loyal?